diff --git a/app/adminapi/lists/marketing/MarketingContractChangeLists.php b/app/adminapi/lists/marketing/MarketingContractChangeLists.php
index 594cbdd63..4dd5e55d8 100644
--- a/app/adminapi/lists/marketing/MarketingContractChangeLists.php
+++ b/app/adminapi/lists/marketing/MarketingContractChangeLists.php
@@ -66,10 +66,10 @@
 				->order(['id' => 'desc'])
 				->select()->each(function ($data) {
 					$contract = MarketingContract::field('contract_name,contract_type,business_nature,signed_amount')->where('id', $data['contract_id'])->findOrEmpty();
-					$data['contract_name'] = $contract?->contract_name;
-					$data['contract_type'] = $contract?->contract_type_text;
-					$data['business_nature'] = $contract?->business_nature_text;
-					$data['signed_amount'] = $contract?->signed_amount;
+					$data['contract_name'] = !$contract->isEmpty() ? $contract['contract_name'] : '';
+					$data['contract_type'] = !$contract->isEmpty() ? $contract->contract_type_text : '';
+					$data['business_nature'] = !$contract->isEmpty() ? $contract->business_nature_text : '';
+					$data['signed_amount'] = !$contract->isEmpty() ? $contract['signed_amount'] : '';
 				})
 				->toArray();
 		}
diff --git a/app/adminapi/logic/marketing/MarketingContractChangeLogic.php b/app/adminapi/logic/marketing/MarketingContractChangeLogic.php
index 5ede14185..f38c83dc3 100644
--- a/app/adminapi/logic/marketing/MarketingContractChangeLogic.php
+++ b/app/adminapi/logic/marketing/MarketingContractChangeLogic.php
@@ -112,10 +112,10 @@
 		{
 			$data = MarketingContractChange::withoutField('create_time,update_time,delete_time')->findOrEmpty($params['id']);
 			$contract = MarketingContract::field('contract_name,contract_type,business_nature,signed_amount')->where('id', $data['contract_id'])->findOrEmpty();
-			$data['contract_name'] = $contract?->contract_name;
-			$data['contract_type'] = $contract?->contract_type_text;
-			$data['business_nature'] = $contract?->business_nature_text;
-			$data['signed_amount'] = $contract?->signed_amount;
+			$data['contract_name'] = !$contract->isEmpty() ? $contract['contract_name'] : '';
+			$data['contract_type'] = !$contract->isEmpty() ? $contract->contract_type_text : '';
+			$data['business_nature'] = !$contract->isEmpty() ? $contract->business_nature_text : '';
+			$data['signed_amount'] = !$contract->isEmpty() ? $contract['signed_amount'] : '';
 			return $data->toArray();
 		}
 	}
\ No newline at end of file